Sunday, 10 June 2012

How much mathematics is there in a maths lesson?

very little - in short.


When I’m preparing lessons I almost start to feel guilty if I don’t make a real life reference and I let my students indulge themselves in mathematics.
A couple of weeks ago I was using a lot of algebra with one of my groups. When the class were getting on with the activity a pupil turns around to me to say – “What is the point in this?! I’m not going to need it again”.

This isn’t an unusual question, especially when you don’t give the students some superficial use of what they are doing. I could have responded with one of the following:

Option 1: Passing the Test
 “You’re right, but unfortunately you need it to pass your GCSE so you need to get on with it.”
Option 2: Utilitarian
 “Well, where do I start? You use it everywhere. In fact, it’s amazing where algebra does turn up! You might need it in business, finance or building for example….”
Option 3: Problem Solving Skills
 “It’s the way it helps you think. By doing this you are able to think more logically which is always going to be useful.”

I think all these option are correct to some extent: Option 1 is true and unfortunately is likely to shut a student up and encourage them to carry on with this “pointless mathematics”. Option 2 is for the utilitarian amongst us and almost gives the students some false hope – they could quite easily turn around and say – but I don’t want to do any of those jobs. And option 3 emphasises the importance of mathematics for problem solving and how it allows one to think logically but if I was focused on getting students to think logically I wouldn’t necessarily be getting them to expand brackets.

I therefore didn’t choose any of the above. I knew this particular child well and have a good relationship with him and instead I said “do you quite like solving them though?” to which he replied “yeah, they’re alright when ya get the answer. I just don’t see the point.” I was grateful this was his reply otherwise I might have had to revert to one of the above options instead. However, I responded with “well, isn’t that enough then. You enjoy it. You’re sat in a maths lesson working on something that can be pretty tricky and you’re enjoying it. It feels good to enjoy things.” Whilst expanding bracket is a tool that is useful when modelling real world situations it can be enjoyable in its own right and it also equips students with a tool to enable them to develop algebra into more complex and elegant mathematics.

As a graduate in mathematics I have the opinion that although mathematics does hold a lot of importance within society and beyond and allows one to think in ways that are useful, I chose to study a mathematics degree because I find it enjoyable. Mathematics is elegant and interesting in its own right. Is there a space in our mathematics classrooms to simply let students enjoy mathematics for what it is instead of dressing it up as a subject that can be applied to everything? At university I studied both pure and applied mathematics. I hope that pure mathematics doesn’t always get pushed aside for a quick application that half the time makes little sense and ends up causing more confusion.

I don’t believe that a GCSE in mathematics really tests students on mathematics and although I have found I am beginning to except this for the current point in my career it is important to remember students have 5 years to pass that exam. Why not teach students proper mathematics for 3 or 4 years and then train them to pass the test in their final year of school? If they’ve been taught mathematics through investigations and exploration they’re likely to find that easy anyway! 

Thursday, 19 April 2012

Oh Ofsted - Let me get this off my chest!

"You need to do this for Ofsted.....", "Ofsted will expect....", "Your books need to be marked by x, y and z so Ofsted know what you're doing.....", "And don't forget to enter your data again, Ofsted need to see the progress made"...

It feels like this is all I hear at work. I understand that any school wants to do well when Ofsted arrive because of publicity and the dread of being put in special measures. But what annoys me the most is how much I disagree with what Ofsted believe, so everyday I feel like I face the dilemma: Do what I think is best for my students or spend all my time doing what I'm told to do which often contradicts my beliefs.

It saddens me when I see teachers who also have passion in the classroom having to sacrifice time that would normally be spent on planning fantastic lessons doing tasks that are purely there to spoon feed to Ofsted a fake picture. This does not mean I think teachers don't do anything but create the illusion that we do. Quite the opposite - we do a lot but it isn't always seen as most important because it doesn't have a level, grade, piece of data or progress attached to it. 

There is probably no point in moaning about these things, however I never want to become a teacher that goes against what I believe in to impress an Ofsted that predominately seem to care about students getting a C and this can be done by demonstrating progress EVERY SECOND of the day. Staying confident that what I do in my practice is best for my students isn't always easy when so many people in school express how important Ofsted is. However, I do share the opinion that a school does need to impress Ofsted and therefore I should act in way that does "tick the boxes" thus, I arrive at a contradiction!

To end on a positive note:
I am looking forward to teaching double year 7 tomorrow.... That year seems to have less pressures attached to it!

Saturday, 25 February 2012

Back to it with 3 course meals

The first week back after half term took a little adjusting too, especially as I have lost my weekend to an IB course. Although, I cannot complain: The sessions have been useful; I've met some interesting people from all around the world; the accommodation has been good and I've grown accustomed to eating full English breakfasts and 3 course meals!

The hardest thing to get used to this week is our brand new lunch system. Now only 30 minutes long with two of my lunches falling IN THE MIDDLE of a lesson. I thought it was going to be a nightmare but from a behavioral management perspective it works really well. From a learning perspective one might chose to argue differently... As part of good professional development it is good to question why it was easier to manage the behavior and it's simply giving students small tasks or breaking up a task into chunks they can handle appeared to make the students easier to motivate. I'm not suggesting every lesson you should break everything up because this could take away the power of independent learning, or prevent students learning that all important "I'm not going to give up" mode of working. However, it has reemphasised the importance of mini plenaries throughout the lesson and having a lunch in the middle welcomed some good AfL practice before letting them rush off to the canteen!

A couple of feel-good notes:

~My year 10's did fantastically in an investigation involving arithmetic sequences and simultaneous equations.* One of the students who often finds the mathematics challenging produced a beautiful proof completely different to my own and then had the confidence to explain how to do it to a boy who got A* in year 9 which was a nice surprise. 

~When I told my year 7's I wouldn't be in for their double lesson on Friday a good majority of the class complained, explaining they liked my lessons. Vuala! I must be doing something right!

For those interested this site has a lot of other excellent higher level investigations and are supplied with useful teaching notes. 

Saturday, 28 January 2012

I will survive... so long as I concentrate on the positives

Term one of my NQT term has been done and the reason for very few posts about it is because I have felt like there isn't enough time in my day.

However, I'm beginning to realise that the only way to survive a career in teaching is to learn to switch off and think of the positives. In a day I can easily pick out at least one negative thing that happens, drawing from the last few weeks I could choose a student throwing a table at me, a glue stick lid being chucked at my face and a string of swear words coming from the persons mouth responsible, students refusing to do ANYTHING or a kid being sick on my classroom carpet. But it's not these things that get to me, it's the massive amount of paper work, data input, school politics, the government saying thigs like "staff morale should be low in a school doing well" and following - what feels like - hundreds of new policies every day, which consequently means I don't have as much time as I'd like to concentrate on teaching.

As mentioned I need to stop pondering on these negative aspects of my job. Instead by focusing on the good things that happen remind why I went into teaching. For example: a child saying "Miss, I loved maths today", an entire year 7 class getting crazily excited in my lesson, getting outstanding in an observation, a student that I'm having a lot of problems with coming to find me - on his own accord - to sincerely apologise for his attitude and students who in September didn't know their times tables being able to divide fractions with very little teacher input.

Thus, I am making this post to remind myself how important it is to remain positive!

Friday, 7 October 2011

Gaining Respect?

Today a student shouted out "whore" whilst completing a worksheet on inverse operations (this would be classed as an extremely minor behavior issue for this specific class by most). This was shortly followed by "you can't use that word when there's a woman in the room", to which the original student replied "That's not going to offend miss cus she's obviously not one!"

I couldn't decide how to react - so I didn't. But on reflection I think both those students who I have really struggled with might be gaining a little bit of respect for me. Even if it is just a little bit. 

On a stronger positive when I set detentions I would say 80% now turn up and when I ask for quiet I get it from every class - even if it does only last a few seconds! I do believe I'm getting there although I also feel like a horrible person being so strict about EVERYTHING. But it does mean I'm able to get stuck into the teaching with some of my classes. 

I've learnt that the regulative discourse (see Bernstein) such as behavior, classroom layout etc is essential to address first. Then you can start to indulge in the more instructional discourse which is where the teaching of mathematics takes place. I'm not saying I've nailed the behavior of each class - my year 8s, for example are still in the stage of teaching them to listen, sit down and engage for more than 10% of the lesson. But I do feel like I'm getting somewhere which will soon be more manageable with a lot of my classes. 


I had an interesting piece of advice the other day from an ex ofsted inspector. He suggested that schools should give the students a rough lesson plan for every lesson. This should include the timings for each activity. He continued by explaining that if a student then realises (and I have not exaggerated the numbers he used) the starter has been going on for 10 minutes and the lesson plan says 7 then the student should politely tell the teacher to move on.....   He was lucky I had to rush off to teach a lesson. Being flexible with our lesson plans is what, in my opinion, makes an outstanding teacher. It means they are concentrating on the learning there and then and making a judgment on what needs more/less time to improve the understanding of the most students in the room. 

I've gone as far as spending an entire lesson on what was meant as a starter activity because I quickly learnt the students did not have a clue what was going on. I'm hardly going to ignore that and move on.

Saturday, 24 September 2011

Let's not use grades to label our students

I'm fed of students telling me their levels and grades and thinking it means something. "I'm a 5b Miss". So what if you are a 5b, 3a, A+?! What does that actually mean? The topics fit into a grade or level so technically if you learn Pythagoras in 2D, for example, your on a C. Push yourself to use it in 3D problems and your up on a B. However, I don't think it's just the content that gets students a better grade on the exam; it's being able to hold more in their memory, think outside the box, apply knowledge, gaining relational understanding, learning to justify etc. I think any topic can be represented at a low or high level, depending on the questioning, and therefore all students should learn the same topics, and grades should be defined through skill instead of topic.

I have a mathematically challenged  year 9 group who are all on a grade U with a couple on an E.  I chose to teach the students laws of indices, even though "this topic is C grade" and therefore am not required to. However, by the end of the lesson every student in the class had successfully found the law of indices for themselves. Not only are they now able to use the rules but they successfully constructed a conceptual understanding of why it works and went on to create their own problems.

The reason I writing this is to remind myself how important it is to walk into your classroom with an expectation that every student will be able to learn something. And this is irrespective of the grade they are on. I learnt that every student was capable to construct a solid understanding but it could be something else that's letting them down, such as knowing the skills to apply their knowledge or communicate it effectively etc. Giving students current grade levels does hold some useful purpose but I think it is so important to never let a grade put a boundary on how much you think a child is capable of learning.

A similar argument can be constructed to rethink the existence of a foundation and higher paper or at least a separate scheme of work for different sets. Just because a child is in a lower set is it really fair that they don't get exposed to certain areas of mathematics? They're definitely not going to understand it if they're not given an opportunity to.

Wednesday, 21 September 2011

45 detentions...

That's how many I gave out today.

I don't think I need to say much more. Today's been tough!