When I’m preparing lessons I almost start to feel guilty if
I don’t make a real life reference and I let my students indulge themselves in
mathematics.
A couple of weeks ago I was using a lot of algebra with one
of my groups. When the class were getting on with the activity a pupil turns
around to me to say – “What is the point in this?! I’m not going to need it
again”.
This isn’t an unusual question, especially when you don’t give
the students some superficial use of what they are doing. I could have
responded with one of the following:
Option 1: Passing
the Test
“You’re right, but
unfortunately you need it to pass your GCSE so you need to get on with it.”
Option 2: Utilitarian
“Well, where do I
start? You use it everywhere. In fact, it’s amazing where algebra does turn up!
You might need it in business, finance or building for example….”
Option 3: Problem
Solving Skills
“It’s the way it
helps you think. By doing this you are able to think more logically which is
always going to be useful.”
I think all these option are correct to some extent: Option
1 is true and unfortunately is likely to shut a student up and encourage them
to carry on with this “pointless mathematics”. Option 2 is for the utilitarian
amongst us and almost gives the students some false hope – they could quite
easily turn around and say – but I don’t want to do any of those jobs. And
option 3 emphasises the
importance of mathematics for problem solving and how it allows one to think
logically but if I was focused on getting students to think logically I wouldn’t
necessarily be getting them to expand brackets.
I therefore didn’t choose any of the above. I knew this
particular child well and have a good relationship with him and instead I said
“do you quite like solving them though?” to which he replied “yeah, they’re
alright when ya get the answer. I just don’t see the point.” I was grateful
this was his reply otherwise I might
have had to revert to one of the above options instead. However, I responded
with “well, isn’t that enough then. You enjoy it. You’re sat in a maths lesson
working on something that can be pretty tricky and you’re enjoying it. It feels
good to enjoy things.” Whilst expanding bracket is a tool that is useful when
modelling real world situations it can be enjoyable in its own right and it
also equips students with a tool to enable them to develop algebra into more complex
and elegant mathematics.
As a graduate in mathematics I have the opinion that
although mathematics does hold a lot of importance within society and beyond
and allows one to think in ways that are useful, I chose to study a mathematics
degree because I find it enjoyable. Mathematics is elegant and interesting in
its own right. Is there a space in our mathematics classrooms to simply let
students enjoy mathematics for what it is instead of dressing it up as a
subject that can be applied to everything? At university I studied both pure
and applied mathematics. I hope that pure mathematics doesn’t always get pushed
aside for a quick application that half the time makes little sense and ends up
causing more confusion.
I don’t believe that a GCSE in mathematics really tests students
on mathematics and although I have found I am beginning to except this for the
current point in my career it is important to remember students have 5 years to
pass that exam. Why not teach students proper mathematics for 3 or 4 years and
then train them to pass the test in their final year of school? If they’ve been
taught mathematics through investigations and exploration they’re likely to find that easy anyway!