I couldn't decide how to react - so I didn't. But on reflection I think both those students who I have really struggled with might be gaining a little bit of respect for me. Even if it is just a little bit.
On a stronger positive when I set detentions I would say 80% now turn up and when I ask for quiet I get it from every class - even if it does only last a few seconds! I do believe I'm getting there although I also feel like a horrible person being so strict about EVERYTHING. But it does mean I'm able to get stuck into the teaching with some of my classes.
I've learnt that the regulative discourse (see Bernstein) such as behavior, classroom layout etc is essential to address first. Then you can start to indulge in the more instructional discourse which is where the teaching of mathematics takes place. I'm not saying I've nailed the behavior of each class - my year 8s, for example are still in the stage of teaching them to listen, sit down and engage for more than 10% of the lesson. But I do feel like I'm getting somewhere which will soon be more manageable with a lot of my classes.
I had an interesting piece of advice the other day from an ex ofsted inspector. He suggested that schools should give the students a rough lesson plan for every lesson. This should include the timings for each activity. He continued by explaining that if a student then realises (and I have not exaggerated the numbers he used) the starter has been going on for 10 minutes and the lesson plan says 7 then the student should politely tell the teacher to move on..... He was lucky I had to rush off to teach a lesson. Being flexible with our lesson plans is what, in my opinion, makes an outstanding teacher. It means they are concentrating on the learning there and then and making a judgment on what needs more/less time to improve the understanding of the most students in the room.
I've gone as far as spending an entire lesson on what was meant as a starter activity because I quickly learnt the students did not have a clue what was going on. I'm hardly going to ignore that and move on.