Thursday, 23 August 2012

It all comes down to a number... so it would seem.

That number being the percentage of students that get 5 A*-C including mathematics and English in your school.

Today is GCSE results day. I walked into my school and was bombarded with percentages left, right and centre. My questions were all about individual students and my answers predominately involved the A*-C kids.

I was lucky to be teaching an express group and so there were no surprises - they all did well. However, there are some students I know that find mathematics more challenging that got a D. I was initially delighted and so were they, but a lot of teachers didn't acknowledge the success of that particular student because they don't help raise the schools important percentage.

Today's situation has left me slightly confused: I think it so important that any student that exceeds their previous performance in a subject should be acknowledged. However, I also find it really hard to accept that there are so many students not getting a C in mathematics. This year to get a C you needed around 26% on two papers and there were a good handful of students that didn't do that.

The biggest problem I have comes back to yet another go at setting. If I had a student that got a D and told you they were in set 1, I'd probably get "what happened?" or "what went wrong". If I now tell you they are in the lowest set of the year I'd probably receive something along the lines of "excellent!" or "should have put them in for higher - they might have got the C!". This suggests that when teachers go into their classrooms and are told the set they are to teach they make a judgement of what grade their students can get, thus having an effect of the tier they get put in for, which will affect the mathematics they are to be taught and this brings us back to the beginning as this will determine the grade they get. My challenge for teachers is to therefore go into your new classrooms and try not to be influenced with the set they are in. I still believe all students can understand mathematics but I don't believe this will be possible if the teacher walks into the room with the idea that their class will be doing all right if they only understand half the syllabus - enough to get them a C. How do you know what half they will understand?

Maybe I should have started the third paragraph with: I was teaching a year 11 group this year and there were no surprises - they all did well.

I know this argument needs more thought and fine tuning. I think I am likely to write my dissertation for my masters on some of these thoughts. I'm interested at looking at at what happens if we teach two very different sets of students the same mathematics with the belief both will understand it. This does, of course, always fall back on my assumption of teaching for a conceptual understanding. Not for the test itself.

To end on a more positive note it was good to see the students you've been teaching itching to tell you the results they got because they are a little bit proud of themselves.